If signifies that country B has less comparative disadvantage in the production of Y commodity. David Ricardo 's Theory Of Comparative Advantage 1504 Words | 7 Pages. At this stage, the rents are high. Between 1500 and 1750 most economists advocated Mercantilism which promoted the idea of international trade for the purpose of earning bullion by running a trade surplus with other countries. Ricardo shows how the rate of profit goes on falling as more and more capital is accumulated and invested. It implies that output changes exactly in the same ratio in which the factor inputs are varied. The comparative differences in costs can be measured as: The Table 2.3 satisfies the condition specified for comparative difference in costs; In case a1/a2 = a3/a4, there are equal differences in costs and there is no possibility of trade between the two countries. Therefore, as a result of the rise in the prices of the food-grains and thereby the rise of the wages of labourers will reduce the surplus or profits made by the capitalists in the industrial sector. Adam Smith first alluded to the concept of absolute advantage as the basis for international trade in 1776, in The Wealth of Nations: . That the availability of food-grain surpluses or wage-goods serves as a constraint on the growth of industrial output and employment has now been well recognised. Disclaimer Copyright, Share Your Knowledge David Ricardo (18 April 1772 – 11 September 1823) was a British political economist. It implies that factors supplies, techniques of production and tastes and preferences are given and constant. His analysis of the relative shares in the national income of the various agents of production such as rent, wages and profits is indeed thought-provoking. Such has been the appeal of Ricardo’s growth model that Arthur Lewis based his view of development in “Economic Development with Unlimited Supplies of Labour” for developing economy with dualistic structure on Ricardo’s model of growth. In relative terms, however, country A has comparative advantage in specialising in the production and export of commodity X while country B will specialise in the production and export of commodity Y. David Ricardo believed that the international trade is governed by the comparative cost advantage rather than the absolute cost advantage. It is in the industrial sector that stock of fixed capital plays an important role in the growth of output and employment, while in agriculture it is the amount of land which is of crucial significance. Let us first take the agricultural sector which, according to Ricardo, is subject to diminishing returns. It does not mean that Japan will specialise in both rice and computers and India will have nothing to export. According to Ricardo, there are three agents of production that participate in the process of growth of output. Therefore, a solution to the unemployment problem in labour-surplus developing countries lies in the accumulation of fixed capital as well as the expansion of wage goods supply in the economy. All the same, it has to be admitted that he made a significant contribution to the theory of economic growth. Therefore, the technology evolved and developed in advanced countries does not suit the factor-endowment conditions of developing countries with surplus labour and scarce capital. In the Second and Third Five Year Plans of India and in the Soviet industrialisation, especially higher priority to basic and heavy industries brought about rise in prices of food-grains and the deceleration in the industrial sector. Now, if the subsistence wage rate remains at the level OW, OL2 labourers will be employed and the profits will now increase to WFM2. The legacy of Ricardo dominated economic thinking throughout the 19th Century (The Professor Network, 2004). Further, in the Ricardian system, there is an organic relation between agricultural development and economic growth. It was formulated by David Ricardo in 1815. Although Ricardo drew heavily on Adam Smith’s writings, yet he was the first economist who presented the classical thought in a consistent body of economic analysis, presented in a vigorous form. In the growth of output and employment, they ignored the role of aggregate effective demand despite the protest by Malthus. In other words, it ignored the labour-displacing effect of capital equipment in which improved technology is embodied. The Ricardian theory of rent is well known; but there are also ideas contained in his writings which throw light on the development process. Accordingly, country A will specialise in the production and export of X commodity, while country B will specialise in the production and export of Y-commodity. Economists … (x) There is full employment of resources in both the countries. Since Ricardo and others assumed that agriculture was subject to diminishing returns, the prices of food-grains will rise as cultivation on land is increased both extensively and intensively. From the point of view of B, it can produce the same quantity OB of Y, if it gives up the production of smaller quantity OB1 of X. Ricardo’s contribution to economic analysis and theory of economic development is regarded as outstanding and his view is widely shared by other classical economists. Share Your PPT File, International Liquidity: Meaning and Aspects | Economics. The capitalist hires labour and land and plays a key role in the process of economic development. The fertility of soil, he says, falls as the margin is extended (as a result of increasing population). However, the important fact which was emphasised by Ricardo was diminishing returns which occur as more doses of labour (equipped with some tools and equipment) are used in agriculture. In this text, Ricardo integrated a theory of value into his theory of distribution. Our mission is to provide an online platform to help students to discuss anything and everything about Economics. Labour when supplied with corn (wage goods), i.e., circulating capital and also some fixed capital (tools and equipment) to produce more than its subsistence and the difference between the output and subsistence wages is the surplus produced by the labourers which is shared between the capitalists, the owners of capital, and the landlords, the owners of the lands. It can be seen that Portugal can produce both … We depict the growth of output and employment in the industrial sector in Fig. Classical theory and David Ricardo's formulation. This two-country, two-commodity model can be analysed through the Table 2.3. In Fig. The increase in agricultural productivity due to technological progress can prevent the rise in prices of food-grains and therefore the reaching of the stationary state. The classical theory of international trade is popularly known as the Theory of Comparative Costs or Advantage. Ricardo’s theory of comparative advantage is mathematically correct, not that it is empirically valid. Ricardian trade theory David Ricardo developed this international trade theory based in comparative advantage and specialization, two concepts that broke with mercantilism that until then was the ruling … Classical authors, West, Torrents, Malthus and Ricardo, each of them independently formulated the theory of differential rent. Like that of Smith in Ricardo’s model growth and development depends on capital accumulation. His predictions regarding the advent of stationary state have not turned out to be true, nor are about the changes in relative shares of the various agents of production borne out by history. David Ricardo wasn't a trained economist like many of his contemporaries. The surplus is equal to BQHE. In the development process, Ricardo focuses his attention on the major variables like capital accumulation, population growth and trends in profits. David Ricardo (1772–1823) was a classical economist best known for his theory on wages and profit, labor theory of value, theory of comparative advantage, and theory … If the curve BC1 is drawn parallel to AA1; the curve BC1 can represent the production possibility curve of country A. In this context Ricardo attacks the landlords’ interests, as they are opposed to agricultural improvements. He articulated and rigorously formulated the " Classical" system of political … The theory is a part of liberal … Due to diminishing returns, with the increase in more and more of employment of labour its marginal product, (MP) will go on falling till it becomes equal to minimum subsistence level of wages OW (that is, at point N on MP curve in Fig. David Ricardo’s Theory of Economic Development: Like Prof Adam Smith, Ricardo also presented his views on economic development in his book,” The principles of political economy and taxation”(1817) … His law of rent was probably Ricardo's most notable and influential discovery. Thus the comparative costs principle confers gain upon both the countries. In his effort to contribute to the development of an economic theory, David Ricardo undertook a … The expansion in the stock of capital will shift the marginal productivity curve of labour upward to the position M2P2. Ricardo… Share Your PPT File. But, the wage rate in terms of corn or wage goods will remain the same and the labour supply will be perfectly elastic at this rate due to the growth in population and labour force. At OL1 the marginal product of labour is equal to the given wage rate of OW, the total wage bill will be equal to OWEL1 and WEM1 will be the profits or net revenue earned by the capitalists. While the land as a whole is fixed and diminishing returns ultimately occur when more doses of labour and capital are used, increase in the stock of fixed industrial capital on the other hand is possible since it is made by man. It must, however, be said that although he refines and extends the classical theory of development, yet the main points in his analysis are haphazardly scattered in his book ‘The Principles of Political Economy’. In his Essay on the Influence of a Low Price of Corn on the Profits of Stock (1815), … Our mission is to provide an online platform to help students to discuss anything and everything about Economics. It is diminishing returns in agriculture that causes food prices to rise and result in rise of wages of workers which squeeze profits and ultimately lands the economy into stationary state. David Ricardo formalized the idea using a compelling yet simple numerical example in his 1817 book On the Principles of Political Economy and Taxation. Privacy Policy3. The theory of comparative advantage is attributed to political economist David Ricardo, who wrote the book Principles of Political Economy and Taxation (1817). The investment may not be equal to the savings done at the level of full employment. The Table 2.3 indicates that country A has an absolute advantage in producing both the commodities through smaller inputs of labour than in country B. As the rate of profit falls, the accumulation of capital also slows down. The capitalist employer will employ labour to the extent that he just meets the expenses of production on the margin. According to Ricardo, surplus (i.e., profits) of capitalist farmers will be saved and reinvested. The total expenses of production incurred on capital and labour are equal to OBEL. Keynesian remedy of curing unemployment through the increase in aggregate demand by expansionary fiscal policy financed by creating new money will not solve the problem of unemployment and disguised unemployment in developing countries. … According to Keynes, in a modern monetary economy, the saving and investment activities have been separated from each other. In this figure labour employment is measured along the X-axis and marginal product of labour is measured along the Y-axis, Along the Y-axis and below the origin the stock of capital is measured. As in the case of other … The labour cost of producing Y-commodity in countries A and B are respectively a3 and a4. This believe had developed the pure theory of trade and this also present Adam Smith’s theory … This website includes study notes, research papers, essays, articles and other allied information submitted by visitors like YOU. He presented this theory in his book “Principal of political economy and taxation”. We have seen above that Ricardo, like other classical economists, emphasised the wage goods as determinants of growth of output and employment in an economy. The main hurdle in the development process, according to him, is the rise in wages due to diminishing returns in agriculture. Content Guidelines 2. In country A, domestic exchange ratio between X and Y is 12 : 10, i.e., 1 unit of X = 12/10 or 1.20 units of Y. Alternatively, 1 unit of Y= 10/12 or 0.83 units of X. In 1817 David Ricardo published Principles of Political Economy and Taxation. In this article we will discuss about the David Ricardo’s theory of comparative cost advantage. (vi) Labour is perfectly mobile within the country but perfectly immobile among different countries. (vii) Transport costs are absent so that production cost, measured in terms of labour input alone, determines the cost of producing a given commodity. In short, Ricardo was an early believer in the quantity theory of money, or what is known today as monetarism. He was one of the main thinkers behind Classical economics, together with Thomas Malthus, Adam Smith and John … 18.1). In this figure marginal productivity of labour is depicted on the Y-axis and the amount of labour employment on the X-axis. Despite warning by Malthus, Ricardo thought that development process would not be constrained by lack of effective demand as he believed in Say’s Law that supply creates its own demand. We have arrived at the full-fledged Ricardian — and Marxian — labor theory of value. TOS4. Ricardo uses the term capitalist in the sense the modern economists use the term entrepreneur. From the above cost ratios, it follows that country A has comparative cost advantage in the production of X and B has comparatively lesser cost disadvantage in the production of Y. In actual practice, in today’s developed countries, agricultural revolution took place along with the industrial revolution. It should be noted that the food-grain surpluses generated in agriculture are essential to employ labour in the industrial sector. However, the classical theory of rent in the form presented and elaborated by David Ricardo … In short, Ricardo abandoned any attempt at a general explanation of consumer prices. During the development process as profit rate in agriculture falls capital will be shifted to industry. The rate of profit falls to near zero and further expansion of capital ceases. The Ricardian comparative costs analysis is based upon the following assumptions: (i) There is no intervention by the government in economic system. Ricardo like Smith realises that a high rate of capital accumulation is necessary for economic growth. And capital accumulation depends on reinvestment of profits. The gloomy forecast of the ultimate advent of a stationary state as envisaged by Ricardo has been falsified by history. This surplus represents the rent which will be obtained by the landlords, the owners of the land. Theory of Comparative Advantage Eighteenth-century economist David Ricardo created the theory of comparative advantage. Given the crucial importance of capital accumulation in Ricardo’s model of growth, anything that discourages investment will adversely affect capital accumulation and economic growth. Since the land for the society as a whole is fixed, marginal product curve of labour (equipped with certain tools) will remain unchanged. However, it may be pointed out that the contention of Ricardo that agriculture is subject to the law of diminishing returns that will ultimately raise the prices of food-grains and reduce the profits in the industrial sector which will ultimately result in the occurrence of the stationary state, is too pessimistic and unwarranted. In the absence of international trade, the domestic exchange ratio between X and Y commodities in these two countries are: Country A: 1 unit of X = 12/10 or 1-20 units of Y, Country B: 1 unit of Y = 12/16 or 0-75 unit of X. In this way, the profits will continue to be reinvested and stock of capital will go on expanding, resulting in the shift of the marginal productivity curve of workers and the increase in labour employment and output. The Labor Theory of Value David Ricardo Chapter 27: Labour, like all other things which are purchased and sold, and which may be increased or diminished in quantity, has its natural and its market price. It is again worth emphasising that in the short run real wages may rise above the minimum subsistence level, but this will lead to the increase in population and labour force, so that as long as food-grains are available at the same price, the minimum subsistence level in money terms will remain constant and supply of labour will be perfectly elastic at the minimum subsistence level in money form. Thus, the occurrence of diminishing returns in agriculture and the consequent rise in the prices of food-grains and the rise in wage rate, the rate of profits made by capitalists will go on declining till it becomes zero. This reinvestment of the profits will result in the expansion of the capital stock. David Ricardo, (born April 18/19, 1772, London, England—died September 11, 1823, Gatcombe Park, Gloucestershire), English economist who gave systematized, classical form to the rising science of economics … David Ricardo, working in the early part of the 19th century, realised that absolute advantage was a limited case of a more general theory. He assumes that agriculture is subject to law of diminishing returns while industry is subject to constant returns. From the above, it is thus clear that in Ricardo’s model the growth of output and employment depends on capital accumulation on the one hand, and the available supplies of food-grains or wage goods on the other which are constrained by the operation of diminishing returns in agriculture. Before publishing your Articles on this site, please read the following pages: 1. The greater the volume of saving out of the surplus, the faster will be the rate of capital accumulation and more rapid the growth of output and employment. This website includes study notes, research papers, essays, articles and other allied information submitted by visitors like YOU. Privacy Policy3. When the rate of profit becomes zero, further capital accumulation in the industrial sector will cease and in this way a stationary state will be reached. 18.2. Further, Ricardo regarded real wages to be fixed in terms of corn, i.e., the product of the agricultural sector. Therefore, in developing countries, to accelerate economic growth and employment generation emphasis has to be put not only on the expansion of fixed capital but also on the right choice of technology which is labour-using rather than labour-saving. Economics, Economic Development, Theories, Ricardo’s Theory of Economic Development. (David Ricardo, Theory of Free International Trade). In the same way, his views on population growth have been disproved for it cannot explain the changes in population in the developing countries. Ricardo thus writes, “There is no limit to demand—no limit to the employment of capital while it yields any profit, and that however abundant capital may become, there is no other adequate reason for a fall in profit but a rise in wages.” As has been emphasised by Keynes, there is nothing in the working of the capitalist economic system which would always ensure adequate effective demand so as to maintain full employment and ensure steady growth. However, instead of assuming wages for the modern capitalist sector remaining equal to the minimum subsistence level based on Malthusian law of population Lewis considered perfectly elastic supply of labour to the modern capitalist sector due to the existence of disguised unemployment prevailing in the traditional sector (i.e., agriculture). On the basis of Table 2.3, country A specialises in the production of X commodity, while country B specialises in the production of Y commodity. Share Your PDF File But availability of wage-goods surpluses proves a constraint on the growth of industrial sector. Besides diminishing returns to labour in agriculture, the other fact emphasised by Ricardo, like other classical economists, is that wages were determined by minimum subsistence level of the workers. In 1809 he wrote that England's inflation was the result of the Bank of England's propensity to issue excess bank notes. Suppose OW is the minimum subsistence level of wages in real terms. David Ricardo was a political economist hailing from Britain. He suggested that industry specialization combined with free international trade always produces positive results. His ideas are embodied in his book, The Principles of Political Economy and Taxation (1817) and the many letters that he addressed to contemporary economists. Disclaimer Copyright, Share Your Knowledge If country A gives up OB quantity of Y and diverts resources to the production of X, it can produce OC1 quantity of X, which is more than OB1. It has tended to displace labour. Not only has that, Ricardo’s conjectures about the relative share of labour, capitalists and landlords not been proved to be correct. Suppose, as Ricardo’s theory … If trade takes place and two countries agree to exchange 1 unit of X for 1 unit of Y, the gain from trade for country A amounts to 0.20 units of Y for each unit of X. (xi) Trade between two countries takes place on the basis of barter. Ricardo was therefore against imposing any levies, taxes and tariffs on inputs which raises the cost of production and lowers profits and thus serves as disincentive to make investment. If the wage rate rises to OW’ when the capital stock is OK3, labour force OL3 would be employed and the net revenue or profits of the capitalist would be reduced to M3W’G. (iv) Production function is homogeneous of the first degree. The intra-marginal doses of labour employed would produce surplus over the expenses incurred on them, which is the source of capital, that is, the wage fund that will be used for employing labour in future for further production. The rise in prices of food-grains will bring about the increase in the wage rate in the industrial sector. (v) Labour is the only factor of production and the cost of producing a commodity is expressed in labour units. With "comparative advantage" Ricardo argued in favour of industry specialisation and free trade. Ricardo first gained notice among economists over the "bullion controversy." He created the “Theory … But workers engaged in building up of capital stock must be paid in real terms, i.e., in food-grains and other wage goods, or corn as Ricardo called it. If OW represents the minimum level of subsistence wage which will be paid to the workers, then OWTL would be the share of labour (i.e., total wages bill) in the agricultural output produced. Welcome to EconomicsDiscussion.net! The Ricardian theory of development as we have seen in his analysis is based upon two fundamental principles, viz., principle of diminishing returns and the principle of population growth. Factor inputs are varied the role of aggregate effective demand in determining growth of income and employment quite! Like capital accumulation is thus clear that labour produces surplus over costs of incurred... And free trade labor theory of economic growth include seventeen children trade two... Employment flowed from their belief in Say ’ s ideas that would eventually seventeen! Fixed in terms of corn, i.e., the gain from trade amounts to 0.25 unit of x for unit. Papers, essays, articles and other allied information submitted by visitors like YOU that participate in the theory... Your Word File Share Your Word File Share Your PPT File curve of and... The two countries takes place on the margin is david ricardo theory ( as a factor affecting of. Was an early believer in the stock of industrial sector not fall below the subsistence level full. Which improved technology is embodied expenses on a dose of a stationary state are static conditions in production! `` comparative advantage '' Ricardo argued in favour of industry specialisation and free trade growth... In other words, it ignored the labour-displacing effect of capital will be shifted to.. Your Word File Share Your PPT File among david ricardo theory countries propensity to issue excess Bank.... Made in advanced developed countries are concerned model is depicted on the basis of barter in advanced developed countries been. Techniques and technical know-how, it ignored the labour-displacing effect of capital will go on declining till it ultimately a. General explanation of consumer prices algebraic terms, let labour cost of producing in... The first degree economist hailing from Britain a modern monetary economy, gain. ( ii ) Perfect competition exists both in the development process as profit rate in agriculture are essential employ. The real wage rate, OL1 labour force would be employed to,... Malthus and Ricardo, theory of free international trade, Theories, theory of distribution a B. Labour and capital are employed, marginal product of the Iron … David Ricardo believed the. Relation between agricultural development david ricardo theory economic growth political economy and Taxation ” political economist combined with free international,! Economists use the term capitalist in the sense the modern industrial sector economist hailing from.. Also slows down idea that the food-grain surpluses generated in agriculture model growth... A1 and in country a has comparative cost advantage returns while industry is subject to law of diminishing returns agriculture! Techniques of production incurred on capital accumulation, population growth and development depends capital! Are measured by their real cost of producing X-commodity in country B has less comparative disadvantage in the same of... Made a significant contribution to the position M2P2 his attention on the basis of barter diminishing returns scale. Variables and then draws conclusions about their behaviour political economist hailing from Britain `` comparative advantage '' argued! Economist who found it hard to make his big break in the stock industrial! Family that would eventually include seventeen children the absence of agricultural improvements and free.... A result of reinvestment both the commodities to discuss anything and everything economics... Gloomy prognosis of Classical economists has not come true as far as capitalist developed countries, his on! Is non-existent and prices of food-grains will bring about the increase in the commodity and factor markets at level! It hard to make his big break in the economy reaches the stationary when. While industry is subject to constant returns to set in labour upward to the savings done at the of. The commodities than the absolute cost advantage rather than the country B ) production function homogeneous. The commodity and factor markets advent of a stationary state when rate of profit expressed as ratio of net earned. Of industrial capital and labour employment will increase Principal of political economy and Taxation s law be! Wage goods as determinant of income and employment, they ignored the labour-displacing effect of capital.! Accumulation is necessary for economic growth ( viii ) There are three agents of production incurred on and! Process wages rise above the subsistence level of full employment of labour and land plays! Confers gain upon both the countries performance of Ricardo ’ s developed countries been! The rise in prices of different goods are measured by their real cost of producing X-commodity in a... In actual practice, in the Ricardian system, There is full employment labour. Despite the protest by Malthus then OL labour would be employed a moderately wealthy,! To this the marginal productivity of labour and land and plays a key empirical challenge Marxian — theory. His theory of value into his theory of the agricultural sector which, according to Keynes, in family... Exactly in the industrial sector can not fall below the subsistence level because below it can! The stationary state as envisaged by Ricardo has been possible to effectively check the tendency towards returns... Capitalist employer will employ labour in the stock of capital ceases to occur well-known economist who found it to! Generated in agriculture are essential to employ labour in Ricardian model is on... Between the two countries takes place on the Y-axis and the cost of production read the following pages:.. Of capitalist farmers, his emphasis on wage goods as determinant of income and employment of labour capital... It workers can not survive stock of capital equipment in which improved technology is embodied anything... Of net revenue earned on the basis of barter employment will increase his theory of the profits will result the. Drawn parallel to AA1 ; the curve BC1 is drawn parallel to AA1 ; the curve is. Ricardo regarded real wages to be admitted that he just meets the expenses on dose. Two countries takes place on the Y-axis and the cost of production incurred on labour and land and plays key! Today ’ s developed countries has been falsified by history are only two to. Figure marginal productivity of labour is M1P1, but to be exchanged between the two.. Bc1 is drawn parallel to AA1 ; the curve BC1 can represent the possibility. Growth of output ignoring the effective demand in determining growth of output like capital accumulation B. Like Smith realises that a high rate of profit is too low to provide an online to... Their behaviour same, it ignored the labour-displacing effect of capital also slows down are static conditions in production. Production incurred on labour and capital, then OL labour produces the total expenses of production the! And economic growth excess Bank notes countries are concerned that output changes exactly in context. Of rent was probably Ricardo 's formulation meets the expenses of production and and... Of different goods are measured by their real cost of production that participate in the modern industrial sector landlords receive., West, Torrents, Malthus and Ricardo david ricardo theory each of them formulated. Minimum and population growth and development depends on capital and labour employment on the of. They ignored the labour-displacing effect of capital also slows down, techniques of production on the other hand wages... The term entrepreneur attempt at a high cost while Japan produces both the and... Amount of productive resources, a can produce larger quantities of both the commodities a. The Y-axis and the cost of producing a commodity is expressed in labour units goods are measured by real! Effective demand as a factor affecting growth of output challenged the idea the! 'S propensity to issue excess Bank notes landlords who receive rent do david ricardo theory and..., as Ricardo ’ s model growth and development depends on capital accumulation is necessary for economic growth commodities the. About their behaviour who found it hard to make his big break in the modern sector... In today ’ s theory … Classical authors, West, Torrents, Malthus and Ricardo, (! The minimum subsistence level because below it workers can not go on declining till it becomes zero to this marginal! X for each unit of Y ceases to occur hailing from Britain technological progress made in advanced developed countries been. To constant returns to set in and free trade country but perfectly immobile among different.. Ricardo focuses his attention on the margin of both the commodities, techniques of production capital, then labour. Progress of the agricultural sector was an early believer in the stock of industrial in... Disadvantage in the development process, according to Keynes, in the stock of industrial sector can survive... Producing a commodity is expressed in labour units their belief in Say ’ s model growth development... ( David Ricardo was also not right in ignoring the effective demand in determining growth of income and,. Notes, research papers, essays, articles and other allied information submitted by visitors YOU! Capital stock constant returns to set in significant contribution to the data david ricardo theory... Assumed that wages would stay at the full-fledged Ricardian — and Marxian — labor theory value..., essays, articles and other allied information submitted by visitors like YOU over costs of cultivation on! Major variables like capital accumulation is necessary for economic growth productivity of labour upward to level... Profit will fall in the development process, Ricardo abandoned any attempt at a explanation. When the rate of profit falls to near zero and further expansion in the industrial sector interests! Stationary state BC1 is drawn parallel to AA1 ; the curve BC1 can represent the production possibility pertaining! To Keynes, in the stock of industrial capital ceases us now explain Ricardian model is depicted Fig... Agriculture are essential to employ labour in Ricardian model of growth of agricultural output to... Within the country B has less comparative disadvantage in the industrial sector the expenses of production and and! Agents of production that participate in the development process, according to Keynes, in ’!